site stats

Could benteen have saved custer

WebAnswer (1 of 5): The best answer to this question probably relies in large part on John Gray’s time motion analysis of the battle, but that analysis breaks down at the end as Gray runs out of reliable data points, so the answer to this question is always going to be a bit subjective. I believe th... WebDiscover and share books you love on Goodreads.

The Last Stand: Custer, Sitting Bull, and the Battle of the Little ...

WebUnlike others in the Seventh Cavalry regiment, Benteen never believed Custer was invincible. Benteen survived because Custer divided his command into three parts. WebJan 20, 2024 · As 2nd Lieutenant Edgerly of Benteen’s command wrote later of Reno’s retreat across the river: “As soon as this …recrossing was made, nearly all the Indians … dr tobler childrens mercy https://mygirlarden.com

Did Reno and Benteen betray Custer? - Quora

WebMay 7, 2010 · Meanwhile, Benteen, sent with his three companies by Custer on an expedition with no recognizable purpose except to cheat him of his share of the expected … WebQuestions have been raised as to whether circumstances might have been different had Benteen, Reno, or Crook promptly acted. ... We would then debate as to whether Custer could have saved Reno. Did Reno panic … WebAnswer (1 of 7): Betray is a harsh word. In the case of Benteen, yes, I think that is accurate. Reno probably requires a more nuanced answer. Let’s consider Benteen first. Benteen held a longstanding grudge against Custer that resulted in a divided officer corps in the 7th. At the Battle of the ... dr tobin testimony

George Custer: An American embarrassment Salon.com

Category:Could Benteen have saved Custer? Little Bighorn History …

Tags:Could benteen have saved custer

Could benteen have saved custer

How Merriweather Lewis

WebFeb 15, 2008 · Private Giovanni Martini was carrying a written order by General Custer: “Benteen, come on, be quick, bring packs.” The packs were not the entire pack train, as it is often stated, but the “extra ammunitions”. ... Nothing could have saved Custer that day except a massive infusion of troops, repeating rifles, or possibly having the ... WebAug 25, 2013 · Officer claimed Custer could have been saved. By CURT ERIKSMOEN. Aug 25, 2013. One of the most enigmatic characters involved in the Battle of the Little …

Could benteen have saved custer

Did you know?

WebOct 31, 2013 · Feel like reading it again myself. According to this analysis of the battle, Reno and Benteen were engaged by the Indian camp first and forced to retreat. Their awakening of the camp (much larger than known by Custer) resulted in Custer's blundering into a large Indian force already on the move, armed and mad. WebJan 30, 2024 · Charlie Windolph died on March 11, 1950, at the age of 99, the last white survivor of the Battle of the Little Bighorn. That summer, again working at the Custer Battlefield, I rode a bus down to Lead and …

WebJan 10, 2009 · Benteen is not blameless in all things, but there is no way he could have saved Custer, IMHO, who was, to all intents and purposes, doomed as soon as he …

WebCapt. Frederick Benteen. Frederick William Benteen was born on August 24, 1834. He entered military service from Missouri as first lieutenant, Company C, Missouri Volunteer … WebBenteen was livid. One of the greatest battles of the frontier was about to take place, and Custer had sent him off on what he thought was a fool’s errand. History has not been …

WebJun 24, 2008 · On that particular day, I seriously doubt if Benteen could have saved Custer. The warriors " medicine" was too good and, "Custer's Luck" abruptly ran out of …

WebAnswer (1 of 2): Short answer: Unlikely. The Gatling gun, as well modern machine guns, are what are known in military parlance as “force multipliers.” The work of a large group of soldiers is done by just one or a few, or at least has that effect. Gatling guns could fire bullets at a rate many t... columbus christian center columbus msWebMay 7, 2012 · Custer Saved the Nation. He is the man everybody loves to hate. George Armstrong Custer, once one of the most admired American military heroes, has become, in our time, one of the most hated figures … dr tobin podiatrist beverly maWebNov 18, 2024 · He died not knowing why Major Marcus Reno and Captain Frederick Benteen never came up in support. ... Custer’s scouts found numerous trails leading to the Little Bighorn, and soon discovered the massive encampment that now held seven different Indian bands in a straight line stretching almost three miles. Even then, Custer did not … columbus christian preschool midland gahttp://astonisher.com/archives/museum/frederick_beneen_little_big_horn.html dr tobin podiatrist raleigh ncWebOne of those officers, Frederick Benteen, would be with Custer at the Little Bighorn, but survive. Though he was later credited with saving the remnants of the regiment, it was … columbus circle covid testingWebUniversity of Michigan. Captain Thomas Benton Weir (September 28, 1838 – December 9, 1876) was an officer in the 7th Cavalry Regiment (United States), notable for his participation in the Battle of the Little Bighorn, … columbus circle hedge fundhttp://armchairgeneral.com/for-want-of-a-saber-the-battle-was-lost-little-bighorn-1876.htm dr tobon dermatology fl